Our sincere thanks and appreciation to Bonnie Shumway, Town Historian of Mexico, N.Y., for contributing this cemetery list and making it available to online researchers. Bonnie has also contributed a wonderful History on the Town of Mexico, and can be read on the Mexico Town Page.  Many thanks also to volunteer, Dianne Thomas, Volney Town Editor, for transcribing this list, and who luckily, likes long and detailed projects. Dianne also volunteers her time transcribing for several other websites, and enjoys being involved in genealogy.
**For further information on any of the names, please contact the local Town Historians / Historical Societies.

MARTIN Levi   1890 aged 78y
MC MILLEN Mary   1847 aged 74y; widow of D. Mc Millen
MOOR Clarissa   1815 or 1845 aged 44y; 1st wife of Valentine
MOOR John   1835 aged 72y; husb of Margaret
MOOR Valentine   1872 aged 70y; husb of Clarissa & Mary DUEL
MOOR(E) Margaret   1810 or 1840 aged 15,or 45 or 75y; wife of John Moor
MOOR(E) Mary DUEL   1889 aged 72y; 2nd wife of Valentine; dau of Nathan & Sally DUEL
OJA Emma   1972 aged 85y; could be in the Phoenix, NY ceme; per SSDI:6/24/1886-2/1972 Pennellville, NY
OJA Erick 1885 1933  
PERRY Lois   1853 aged 51y; wife of Sylvenus
P. J.A.     only A marker J.A.P. with marker M.S.R.
PLACE Joanna   1871? aged 71y?; wife of Joshua T.
PLACE Joshua T. Aug?23, 1817 1897 husb of Joanna
POTTER Eda F. 1872 1879 dau of Orlo C. & Ida L.
POTTER Ida L. TULLAR 1841 1899 wife of Orlo C.
POTTER Mattie E. TOOLEY 1849 1917 wife of Orlo C.
POTTER Orlo C. 1843 1906 husb of Ida L. TULLAR & Mattie E. TOOLEY
POWERS Diana   1853 aged 41y
POWERS Martha (Mattie)     see WILKINSON
POWERS Mary S.   1867 aged 39y,11m; wife of Silas
POWERS Silas   1871 aged 63y; husb of Mary S.
POWERS Wilie S.   1863 aged 2 or 7y,11m,12d; son of Silas & Mary E.
PRESTON Emerson   1884 aged 91y,4m; husb of Mariam MARTIN
PRESTON Frederick H.   1862 aged 24y,9d; son of E. & H.
PRESTON Jennie F.   1867 aged 19y,10m,13d; dau of E. & H.
PRESTON Mariam MARTIN 1814 1888 wife of Emerson
PRESTON Martha A.   1867 aged 24y,5m,15d; dau of E. & H.
PROUTY Elise E. THOMPSON   1858 aged 55y,21d; wife of Salmon
PROUTY Esther Ann VAN WORMER Rome, NY 1889 aged 52y
PROUTY Lucretia G.   1869 aged 25y,4m; wife of Nelson
PROUTY R. Henry   1895 aged 70y; son of Salmon & Elise (THOMSON) Prouty
PROUTY Salmon   1863 aged 62y,11m; husb of Elise E. THOMPSON
RAYMOND A.E. or A.F. 1780 1862  
RAYMOND Emily   1875 aged 56y; wife of N. Raymond
RAYMOND N.   1862 aged 45y; husb of Emily
REMINGTON Amelia A.   1855 aged 27y; wife of Sheldon
REMINGTON Ann Eliza HOGOBOOM 1833 1908 wife of LeRoy; dau of Samuel & Fidelia (GREEN) HOGOBOOM
REMINGTON Augusta A. 1827 1867 1st wife of Benjamin
REMINGTON Benjamin 1827 1906 husb of Augusta A. & Mina DAVIS
REMINGTON Elizabeth   1902 aged 72y; wife of Sheldon
REMINGTON Elsworth L. 1863 1935 husb of Hattie POTTER; son of LeRoy & Ann E.
REMINGTON Gifford or Gilford A. 1853 1886 son of Leroy & Ann E.
REMINGTON Hattie POTTER 1870 1902 or 1903 wife of Elsworth; dau of Orlo & Ida (TULLAR) POTTER
REMINGTON Joseph   1857 aged 58y,9m
REMINGTON LeRoy 1830 1910 husb of Ann Eliza; son of Joseph & Lydia (GILBERT) Remington
REMINGTON Lue L. 1860 1863 dau of Benjamin & Augusta A.
REMINGTON Lydia GILBERT   1876 aged 73y; wife of Joseph
REMINGTON Mahlon H. 1856 1944 burial permit says Primitive Cemetery
REMINGTON Mary S.   1855 aged 54y,7m,6d
REMINGTON Mina DAVIS 1836 1910 2nd wife of Benjamin
REMINGTON Renette DAVIS 1854 1866 (E.S.) or 1906 dau of Benjamin & Augusta A.
REMINGTON Sheldon   1900 aged 76y; husb of Amelia A. & Elizabeth L.
R. M.S.     grave marker with J.A. P., near F. & M. Huntington Graves
RIO Dorothy BRADSHAW 1924 1970 wife of Leo E.; WWII bride
RIO Floyd B. 1880 1948 husb of Grace ABBOTT
RIO Grace Violet ABBOTT 1890 1970 wife of Floyd B.; per SSDI: 1/9/1890-10/1970 Syracuse, NY
RIO Leo E. 1914   husb of Dorothy BRADSHAW; WWII Vet; per SSDI:1/25/1914-1/28/1999 Central Sq., NY
RIO Myrle A. 1917 1917 dau of Floyd & Grace
RIO Raymond George 1925 1925 son of Floyd & Grace
SHUMWAY Amasa   1854 aged 65y,8m,8d; 2 children
SHUMWAY Anna E.   1836 aged 2y,4m,18d; dau of A.S. (II) Shumway
SHUMWAY William G.   1835 aged 2y,10m,18d; dau of A.S. (II) Shumway
SMEDLEY Florence A. 1854 1856 dau of James & Laurealia
SMEDLEY James 1829 1899 husb of Laurealia; Civil War Vet
SMEDLEY Laurealia HUNTINGTON 1827 1912 wife of James; "Womans Relief"
SMITH Catherine W.     see HOGOBOOM
SPARKS Lydia M.     see CLARK
SPENCER Lucretia KNAPP   1887 aged 73y; dau of Mathia & Elizabeth KNAPP
STEVENS Anna R.LONGSHORE 1874 1939 wife of Edward H; stillborn child b1914, buried at home
STEVENS Delight KNAPP 1804 1883 wife of Harrison; dau of Matthew & Elizabeth (BEACH or Besch?) KNAPP
STEVENS Harrison 1814 1886 husb of Delight; son of Luther ; ledger says buried in Mexico Ceme.
STEVES Ross Langshore 1909 1971 husb of Stella PIZON; burial permit: Stevens; per SSDI Ross STEVENS 4/16/1909-8/1971 Mexico, NY
STEVES Stella PIZON 1916 1982 wife of Ross Langshore Steves; also married a DUELLS
SUMNER Jerusha     see WHITNEY
SUMNER Levi 1772 1815 or 1850  
TALLMAGE Hannah Mary     see HOGOBOOM
TEMPLE Andrew   1865 aged 34y,5m,19d;
TEMPLE Eliza KELLEY 1843 1899 wife of Swan B.; dau of John & Mary KELLEY
TEMPLE Frank C. 1866 1888 son of Swan B. & Eliza
TEMPLE Myrtle 1875 1885  
TEMPLE Parmenas   1850 aged 67y; husb of Sarah
TEMPLE Sarah   1858 aged 52y; wife of Parmenas
TEMPLE Swan B. 1830 1877 husb of Eliza
THURSTON David 1770 1853 husb of Rachel
THURSTON Rachel 1771 1860 wife of David
TILTON Avis   1876 aged 56y; wife of George
TILTON Charley B.   1867 aged 1y,11m5d; son of Smith G. & Sarah M.
TILTON George W.   1884 aged 62y; husb of Avis
TILTON Hattie E.   1864 aged 3y,4m; dau of Smith G. & Sarah M.
TILTON John Jr.   1879 aged 60y; son of John & Mahala
TILTON John   1851 aged 61y,10m,21d; husb of Pamelia
TILTON Leverette   1864 aged 5y;son of John & Mahala
TILTON Mahala WHITNEY 1822 1910 wife of John
TILTON Nellie   1879 aged 22y; dau of George & Avis
TILTON Pamella   1845 aged 50y,6m,20d; wife of John
TILTON Sarah M. GILLMORE 1830 1907 wife of Smith G; dau of Wm. & Eliza (BURITT) GILLMORE; ledger says son Ralph D; also has husband Orville
TILTON Smith G.   1882 aged 59y,7m,18d; husb of Sarah M.
TOOLEY Mattie E.     see POTTER
TULLAR Abby FLINT 1828 1920 wife of M.M. Tullar
TULLAR Elon   1863 aged 28y,1m; son of Harvey & Lorany
TULLAR Harvey   1870 aged 76y; husb of Lorany
TULLAR Lorany   1883 aged 80y; wife of Harvey
TULLAR Luie A.   1869 1y,8m; dau of M.M. & Abby
TULLAR M.M. 1829 1913 husb of Abby FLINT
TULLAR Melva M. 1876 1892 dau of Ogilvie & Olive U.
TULLAR Ogilvie H. 1838 CA husb of Olive U.
TULLAR Olive U. 1843 CA wife of Ogilvie H.
TULLAR Polly   1837 aged 39y; wife of Orrin
TYLER Abigail   1853 aged 69y; wife of John; also 2 field stones B.T & E.T.
TYLER Sally M.   1898 aged 78y; widow
VALENTINE David   1874 aged 80y; husb of Lucinda & Lucy
VALENTINE Henry M.   1864  
VALENTINE Lucinda   1879 aged 76y; wife of David
VALENTINE Lucy   1832 aged 36y; wife of David
VAN WORMER Esther Ann     see PROUTY
WALT Eunice   1852 aged 37y,3m,223d; wife of Jonathan
WALTON Alice P. 1854 1854 dau of Joshua & Rebecca
WALTON Frances A.   1860 or 1866? aged 1y,7m
WALTON Harland P. 1842 1843 son of Joshua & Rebecca
WALTON Joshua 1814 1889 husb of Rebecca
WALTON Marceline 1848 1849 dau of Joshua & Rebecca
WALTON Morris J. 1854 1855 son of Joshua & Rebecca
WALTON Myron G. 1855 1855 son of Joshua & Rebecca
WALTON Rebecca KENYON 1817 1904 wife of Joshua
WELLWOOD Emma   1867 aged 15y,10m,7d
WELLWOOD Esther   1868 aged 80y,5m,20d
WELLWOOD James (Dr.)   1902 aged 91y
WELLWOOD John   1894 aged 50y,4m,15d; son of James & Sally
WELLWOOD Margaret   1872 aged 40y; wife of Joshua
WELLWOOD Sally   1878 aged 63y,12d; wife of John
WELLWOOD Thompson R.   1857 aged 17y,22d
WHEELER Louisa M. COLE   1897 aged 78y; dau of Luther M.
WHITE Cor.   1877 aged 71y; husb of Sarah
WHITE Sarah   1878 aged 77y; wife of Cor. White
WHITEHEAD Betsey E.   1867 aged 83y; wife of N.B.
WHITEHEAD Ezra T.   1887 aged 71y; son of Titus & Elizabeth
WHITEHEAD N.B.   1870 aged 87y; husb of Betsey E.
WHITNEY Caroline A. ADAMS   1901 aged 81y; wife of Jas. R.
WHITNEY Charles I(L) 1851   husb to 2nd wife, Mary M. ADAMS; also an infant son buried here
WHITNEY Cyrus 1842 1921 husb of Libbie JACOBS; son of Horace & Laura (SHERMAN) Whitney
WHITNEY Elizabeth   1910 aged 67y; dau of Lorenzo & Julia (PIRRO) JACOBS
WHITNEY Eliphalet   1846 or 1847 aged 65y,10m,19d; husb of Lucy
WHITNEY Helen C. (Ellen)     see GILLETTE
WHITNEY Ermina   1851 aged 41y,1m; wife of Joshua
WHITNEY George B. 1846 1932  
WHITNEY Harriet R.   1907 same as ?????
WHITNEY Harriet GILLETT   1907 aged 82y; wife of Seymour
WHITNEY Hezekiah   1842 aged 75y; husb of Susanna
WHITNEY Horace 1807 1894 husb of Laura SHERMAN; son of Eliphalet & Lucy
WHITNEY Infant son   1879 son of Charles L. & Mary M.
WHITNEY Jane S. 1819 1883 wife of Lyman E.
WHITNEY Jas. R.   1885 aged 66y,11m; husb of Caroline A. ADAMS
WHITNEY Jerusha SUMNER 1798 1852 wife of Joseph
WHITNEY J. Morris 1858 1863  
WHITNEY John F. 1829 1863 son of Jonathan
WHITNEY Jonathan   1870 aged 76 - over 80; husb of Sarah, Milena, Louisa & Polly; "WE LOVED HIM" on stone
WHITNEY Joseph 1798 1871 husb of Jerusha SUMNER
WHITNEY Joshua   1863 aged 59y,5m,22d; husb or Ermina
WHITNEY Laura   1861 aged 42y,9m,13d; wife of James
WHITNEY Laura   1883 aged 80y
WHITNEY Louisa   1830 aged 23y; 3rd wife of Jonathan
WHITNEY Lucinda   1878 aged 69y; dau of Eliphalet & Lucy ???
WHITNEY Lucinda HOWARD 1829 1915 dau of Dexter & Rosina (PARKHURST) Howard
WHITNEY Lucy ELSWORTH   1874 aged 91y,6m,20d; wife of Eliphalet
WHITNEY Lucy   1864 aged 2y; dau of Seymour & Harriet
WHITNEY Lucy A.   1856 aged 30y; dau of Eliphalet & Lucy
WHITNEY Lucy T. 1824 1890 wife of John C.
WHITNEY Luly   1864 aged 2y; dau of Seymour & Harriet (could be same as Lucy)
WHITNEY Luna   1861 or 1864 aged 4y,2m,19d; dau of Jas. R & Caroline
WHITNEY Lyman E. 1812 1884 husb of Jane S.
WHITNEY Maryett/Margaret 1844 1903  
WHITNEY Mary M. ADAMS 1848   wife of 2nd husb Charles I(L); and infant son
WHITNEY Milena   1827 aged 19y; 2nd wife of Jonathan
WHITNEY Morris P.   1861 or 1864 aged 12y,10m,20d; son of Joshua & Ermina
WHITNEY Polly   1856 aged 64y; wife of Jonathan
WHITNEY Susanna   1841 aged 70y; wife of Hezekiah
WHITNEY Sarah   1825 aged 31y; 1st wife of Johnathan
WHITNEY Seymour   1885 aged 63y; husb of Harriett GILLETT; son of Eliphalet & Lucy (ELSWORTH) Whitney
WILKINSON Florance 1885   wife of Ralph W.
WILKINSON Mattie M. or M. Martha POWERS 1857 1886 wife of Wm. B; dau of J.H. & Emily (BARBER) POWERS
WILKINSON Ralph W. 1883   husb of Florance L, 2nd wife.; per SSDI 1/30/1883-6/1966 Williamstown, Oswego Cnty, NY
WILKINSON William B. 1852   husb to 2nd wife, Mattie M.
WILLIS Caleb   1872 aged 73y
WILLIS George E.   1862 aged 11y,4m,10d; son of Edward & Rachel A.
WILLIS Rachel A.   1872 aged 44y; wife of Edward

Back to Cemetery Page

Back to Town of Mexico

Return to the Oswego County homepage

Copyright 2001 Bonnie Shumway
Copyright 2001 Dianne Thomas / Laura Perkins
All Rights Reserved